Interactive Calculator: Convert any baking recipe to use unfed sourdough discard with automatic flour, liquid, and baking soda acid-neutralization math using the Sourdough Discard Recipe Substitution Calculator.
To add 100g of 100%-hydration sourdough discard to any conventional baking recipe (pancakes, waffles, banana bread, muffins, or pizza dough) for tangy flavor without changing batter consistency, subtract 50g of flour (about ⅓ cup + 1 tbsp) and subtract 50g of liquid (water, milk, or buttermilk, about 3½ tablespoons) from the recipe. For every 100g of acidic discard added to quick breads or cookies, add ¼ teaspoon (1.2g) of baking soda to neutralize lactic/acetic acid and prevent a dense, gummy crumb.

Because 100% hydration discard is equal parts flour and water by weight ($50\%\text{ flour} + 50\%\text{ water}$), divide your discard weight in half:
| Sourdough Discard Added | Subtract From Recipe Flour (g) | Approx. Volume Flour Removed | Subtract From Recipe Liquid (g/mL) | Approx. Volume Liquid Removed | Baking Soda Booster (Optional for Quick Breads) | Ideal Recipe Size / Application |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50g Discard | −25g Flour | ~3 Tbsp | −25g Liquid | ~1⅔ Tbsp | +⅛ tsp (0.6g) | Small-batch cookies (requires browning butter) |
| 75g Discard | −37.5g Flour | ~¼ cup + 1 Tbsp | −37.5g Liquid | ~2½ Tbsp | +3/16 tsp (0.9g) | Single-skillet cornbread or 6 cupcakes |
| 100g Discard | −50g Flour | ~⅓ cup + 1 Tbsp | −50g Liquid | ~3⅓ Tbsp (50 mL) | +¼ tsp (1.2g) | 12 Muffins, Banana Bread, or Pancake Batter |
| 120g Discard | −60g Flour | ~½ cup | −60g Liquid | ~¼ cup (60 mL) | +¼ tsp (1.4g) | Standard 1-cup flour/liquid replacement unit |
| 150g Discard | −75g Flour | ~⅔ cup | −75g Liquid | ~⅓ cup (75 mL) | +⅜ tsp (1.8g) | Waffles, cinnamon rolls, soft pretzels |
| 200g Discard | −100g Flour | ~¾ cup + 1 Tbsp | −100g Liquid | ~⅓ cup + 1½ Tbsp | +½ tsp (2.4g) | 2-Loaf Quick Bread, Brioche, or 2 Pizza Doughs |
| 250g Discard | −125g Flour | ~1 cup | −125g Liquid | ~½ cup + 1 tsp | +⅝ tsp (3.0g) | Large batch sourdough discard crackers or bagels |
| 300g Discard | −150g Flour | ~1¼ cups | −150g Liquid | ~⅔ cup (150 mL) | +¾ tsp (3.6g) | Family-size sheet pan focaccia or waffle batch |
If you maintain a stiff starter or liquid levain at hydration $H_s$ (as a decimal), the exact flour and water inside $D$ grams of discard are:
\[F_{\text{discard}} = \frac{D}{1 + H_s}, \qquad W_{\text{discard}} = D - F_{\text{discard}}\]| Discard Weight ($D$) | 60% Stiff Discard (Subtract Flour / Water) | 80% Medium Discard (Subtract Flour / Water) | 100% Standard Discard (Subtract Flour / Water) | 125% Liquid Discard (Subtract Flour / Water) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100g Discard | −62.5g Flour / −37.5g Water | −55.6g Flour / −44.4g Water | −50.0g Flour / −50.0g Water | −44.4g Flour / −55.6g Water |
| 150g Discard | −93.8g Flour / −56.2g Water | −83.3g Flour / −66.7g Water | −75.0g Flour / −75.0g Water | −66.7g Flour / −83.3g Water |
| 200g Discard | −125.0g Flour / −75.0g Water | −111.1g Flour / −88.9g Water | −100.0g Flour / −100.0g Water | −88.9g Flour / −111.1g Water |
Chocolate chip cookies have zero added water or milk—their only liquid comes from eggs (~75% water) and unsalted butter (~16%–18% water). To add 60g–80g of sourdough discard to cookies without making them cakey:
Use 150g Sourdough Discard in Moist Banana Bread (-75g Flour, -75g Liquid)